Which Paper for MTG Proxies?

Creating custom MTG proxies is one of the best ways to personalize your deck, test new ideas, or bring your favorite cards to life with unique artwork. But choosing the right paper can make a huge difference in how your cards look and feel. Here's a simple guide to help you decide which option is best for your needs.

Partial Foil – Premium Without Overdoing It

If you want your cards to stand out while keeping a clean and professional appearance, Partial Foil is the ideal choice. Only the artwork receives the holographic treatment, while the text box and borders remain clear and easy to read.

This finish creates a striking visual effect without making the card look overly flashy. It's perfect for players who want a premium custom card that sparks conversation whenever it hits the table.

Holo Foil – Maximum Shine

For players who love eye-catching cards, Holo Foil delivers the full experience. The holographic finish creates a vibrant, reflective look that immediately grabs attention.

Whether it's a showcase commander or a favorite collectible, holo foil cards are designed to be noticed. If your goal is to add as much shine and visual impact as possible, this is the option to choose.

Standard Paper – Affordable and Practical

Not every proxy needs a premium finish. Standard Paper is a great choice for playtesting new decks, casual games, or anyone looking for a budget-friendly option.

The print quality remains vibrant and detailed, making it easy to enjoy custom cards without spending extra on specialty finishes. It's the perfect balance between quality and affordability.

S30 Black Core – Closest to Authentic

For players who want the most realistic experience possible, S30 Black Core is the top-tier option. This cardstock closely matches the feel, weight, and quality of official trading card game cards.

The result is a premium proxy that feels authentic in hand and looks fantastic in a deck. If quality is your highest priority, S30 Black Core is the clear winner.

Which Option Should You Choose?

The best paper depends on what you're looking for:

• Partial Foil for a premium look with selective holographic effects.
• Holo Foil for maximum shine and visual impact.
• Standard Paper for affordable playtesting and casual use.
• S30 Black Core for the closest feel to authentic TCG cards.

No matter which option you choose, the right paper can elevate your MTG proxies and make your custom cards even more enjoyable to play.